| Year | Champ | Runner-up | MVP | MV Pitcher (if listed) |
| 1975 | Neal’s Truck Parts, Grand Rapids, MI | Green Terrace, Winona, WI | N/A | not awarded |
| 1976 | Apple Auto, Millersville, PA | Neal’s Truck Parts, Grand Rapids, MI | N/A | Jerry Grontz, Apple Auto |
| 1977 | Miami Sawaia’s, Miami, FL | North Bay Merchants, Petaluma, CA | Adolpho Mercado, Miami Sawaia’s | |
| 1978 | S&K Rigging, Arcola, IL | Granada Realty, Fremont, CA | Chuck Caldera, Granada Realty | |
| 1979 | Joaquin Construction, Modesto, CA | Montgomery Steelers, Montgomery, AL | Jim Bryan, Joaquin Construction | Hal Skinner, Joaquin Construction |
| 1980 | S.H. Good, New Holland, PA | Blitz-Weinhard, Medford, OR | Jimmy Moore, Blitz | |
| 1981 | S.H. Good, New Holland, PA | Savala Painters, Long Beach, CA | Rex Giberson, S.H. Good | |
| 1982 | The Tee House, Modesto, CA | Albuquerque A’s, Albuquerque, NM | N/A | |
| 1983 | Holiday Markets, Chico, CA | Mitchell Corporation, Corunna, MI | John Hohse, Holiday Markets | |
| 1984 | Hudson Supply, Bakersfield, CA | Lowder Electric, Bakersfield, CA | Keith West, Landmark Chevrolet | |
| 1985 | ETV Trucking, Grand Rapids, MI | Stewart-Taylor-Printing, Duluth, MN | Dave Ganton, ETV Trucking | |
| 1986 | Tubbs & Son Electric, Manteca, CA | Raymax, Burbank, CA | Pete Duenas, Tubbs & Sons Electric | |
| 1987 | Jolly Molly Softball, Lebanon, PA | Magna Plating, Burbank, CA | Roy Himmelberger, Jolly Molly Softball | |
| 1988 | Stewart Taylor, Duluth, MN | Columbus Metros, Columbus, OH | Brian Langeland, Stewart Taylor | |
| 1989 | Texas Flyers, Webster, TX | DC Tire, Philadelphia, PA | Troy Brooks, Texas Flyers | |
| 1990 | Marshall Jazz, Marshall, MO | Louisville Lasers, Louisville, KY | Terry Luster, Marshall Jazz | |
| 1991 | Springers, Boulder, CO | Vista Bombers, Rossmoor, CA | Randy Devenport, Springers | |
| 1992 | DC Tire, Reading, PA | Buchmiller Plastering, Lodi, CA | Mike Smith, DC Tire | |
| 1993 | Broken Bow Travelers, Broken Bow, NE | Classic Pool & Spa, Omaha, NE | Darren Dubsky, Classic Pool & Spa | |
| 1994 | DC Tire, Reading, PA | TSB Merchants, Oakdale, CA | Rod Jarvis, DC Tire | |
| 1995 | Happy Chef, Mankato, MN | Kokomo Pride, Kokomo, IN | Matt Haefner, Happy Chef | |
| 1996 | Hy-Line Enterprises, Elkhart, IN | Wilson Trophy, Stockton, CA | Darrell Bender, Hy-Line Enterprises | |
| 1997 | DC Tire Roadrunners, Reading, PA | VCJ Athletics, Duluth, MN | Mike Ohl, DC Tire | |
| 1998 | DMS Knights, Fargo, ND | Hobnobber Tavern, Seattle, WA | Scott Deutsch, DMS Knights | |
| 1999 | Texas Flyers, Houston, TX | The Freight, Vandalia, IL | Bryan Neal, Texas Flyers | Stoney Burke, Texas Flyers |
| 2000 | All Season Patriots, Allentown, PA | Capital City Chaos, Dawson, IL | David Stokes, All Season Patriots | |
| 2001 | Cancelled due to rain | |||
| 2002 | Lyons, Fresno, CA | Maverick Electric, Stockton, CA | Shawn Mandolesi, Lyons | Tony Peoples, Lyons |
| 2003 | Barley Pop A’s, Minot, ND | Image Solution Knights, Fargo, ND | Rick Lang, Barley Pop A’s | |
| 2004 | McKie Sports, Oswego, NY | Keating Fitness, Wilkes-Barre, PA | Charlie Walsman, KcKie Sports | David Stokes, Keating Fitness |
| 2005 | CR DeMarini Portland, OR | Kreider & Flick, Lancaster, PA | Brian Kaneshige, CR Demarini | Mark Bennett, CR Demarini |
| 2006 | New Image, Mt. Horeb, WI | Rudd’s Team & Trophy, Peoria, IL | ||
| 2007 | The Freight, Vandalia, IL | New Image, Mt. Horeb, WI | ||
| 2008 | Italian Athletic Club, Stockton, CA | New Image Fastpitch, Montfort, WI | Tony Peoples, Italian Athletic Club | |
| 2009 | Lightning, Marshall, MI | New Image Fastpitch, Montfort, WI | Sean Kelly, Lightning | |
| 2010 | Italian Athletic Club, Stockton, CA | Silverhawks, Bakersfield, CA | Tyson Barkman, Italian Athletic Club | |
| 2011 | Columbia River A1 Rockies, Portland, OR | Italian AC, Stockton, CA | Juan Petoluccio, Columbia River A1 Rockies | |
| 2012 | New Image, Mt. Horeb, WI | Sioux Falls Sox, Dell Rapids, IA | ||
| 2013 | eventhelper.com, Grass Valley, CA | Columbia River Brewers, Van., WA | Shawn Mendullsi, Columbia River A1 Rockies | |
| 2014 | Sioux Falls Sox, Sioux Falls, SD | Crow Bar, Sioux Falls, SD |
In 2015 the Men’s A Fastpitch National tournament was discontinued. Starting in 2016, Class A, Class B, and Class C were combined into East and West Open tournaments and also gold and silver flights.
| Year | Class | Champion | Runner-Up |
| 2016 | East Gold | Blues FP, Hastings, MI | Marshall Lightning, Marshall, MI |
| 2016 | West Gold | CR Bartels Farms, Vancouver, WA | Roseville Eagles, Lincoln, CA |
| 2016 | East Silver | Tiffany’s Fastpitch. Saginaw, MI | Diamond Dogs, Wabash, IN |
| 2016 | West Silver | Oregon Cascades, Wilsonville, OR | Interbay Door, Seattle, WA |
| 2017 | East Gold | Twin City Gray Sox, St. Joseph, MI | McDaniel Concrete, Bunceton, MO |
| 2017 | West Gold | Cancelled | |
| 2017 | East Silver | Central Illinois Knights, Camargo, IL | DC Outlaws, Elkhart, IN |
| 2017 | West Silver | Cancelled | |
| 2018 | East Gold | Michigan Snappers, Dimondale, MI | Twin City Gray Sox, Sawyer, MI |
| 2018 | West Gold | Cancelled | |
| 2018 | East Silver | DC Outlaws, Elkhart, IN | Teutopolis Merchants, Teutopolis, IL |
| 2018 | West Silver | Cancelled | |
| 2019 | East Gold | Snappers, Kingsley, MI | Marshall Lightning, Marshall, MI |
| 2019 | West Gold | Cancelled | |
| 2019 | East Silver | Tiffany’s, Frankenmuth, MI | Twin City Gray Sox, St. Joseph, MI |
| 2019 | West Silver | Cancelled | |
| 2020 | East Gold | Snappers, Kingsley, MI | Tiffany’s, Frankenmuth, MI |
| 2020 | West Gold | Cancelled | |
| 2020 | East Silver | Cancelled | |
| 2020 | West Silver | Cancelled | |
| 2021 | East Gold | Rebels Softball Club, Clyde, MI | Tiffany’s, Frankenmuth, MI |
| 2021 | West Gold | Cancelled | |
| 2021 | East Silver | McBain/Michigan Events, Pinckney, MI | AJ Masonry Sting, Wabash, IN |
| 2021 | West Silver | Cancelled |
