| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | MVP |
| 2011 | Flashback, Mt. Prospect, IL | Windy City, Mt. Prospect, IL | Jake Olson, Flashback |
| 2012 | Windy City, Franklin Park, IL | Jynx, Chicago, IL | MVP-not listed |
| 2013 | Windy City, Franklin Park, IL | Impact, Mt. Prospect, IL | Mark Holstein, Windy City |
| 2014 | Signature, Forest Park, IL | Oldtimers, IA | Chris Geron and Mark Holstein, Signature (Co-MVP’s) |
| 2015 | Flashback, Mt. Prospect, IL | Tito’s 45’s, Forest Park, IL | Anthony Coia, Flashback |
| 2016 | Tito’s 45’s, Forest Park, IL | Flashback, Mt. Prospect, IL | Keith Filkins, Tito’s 45’s |
| 2017 | Tito’s 45’s, Forest Park, IL | Hexx, Forest Park, IL | Bill Smith and Joe Yarus, Tito’s 45’s |
| 2018 | Signature, Forest Park, IL | Psychopaths, Lomita, CA | Eric Davis, Signature |
| 2019 | Flashback, Mt. Prospect, IL | Old Timer Tavern, Marshalltown, IA | Ralph Lawrence and Justin Symkowski, Flashback (Co-MVP’s) |
| 2020 | Signature, Forest Park, IL | Tito’s 45’s, Forest Park, IL | Angelo Alysia and Anthony Scarlata, Signature (Co-MVP’s) |
| 2021 | Tito’s 45’s, Forest Park, IL | Flashback, Mt. Prospect, IL | Chris Lentine and Anthony Sanchez, Tito’s (Co-MVP’s) |
