| Year | Champion | Runner-Up |
| 1985 | Polsky-Herzog, St. Joseph, MO | Tulsa, Tulsa, OK |
| 1986 | Polsky-Herzog, St. Joseph, MO | Christian County National Bank, Springfield, MO |
| 1987 | Tulsa Masters, Tulsa, OK | ERS, Minneapolis, MN |
| 1988 | Silver Hawks, Tulsa, OK | ERS, Minneapolis, MN |
| 1989 | Bank of Melrose, Melrose, WI | Roos Masters, Washington, DC |
| 1990 | Townhouse Pizza, Sioux City, IA | Greenwood Inn/Roos Masters, Washington, DC |
| 1991 | Superior Office Products, Sikeston, MO | Frontier Yellow Pages, Bismarck/Fargo, ND |
| 1992 | Nor Cal Merchants, Stockton, CA | Southern California Eagles, San Diego, CA |
| 1993 | Nor Cal Merchants, Stockton, CA | Townhouse Pizza, Sioux City, SD |
| 1994 | Nor Cal Merchants, Stockton, CA | Progressive Solutions, Phoenix, AZ |
| 1995 | Knoll Lumber Legends, Seattle, WA | Maryland Masters, Waldorf, MD |
| 1996 | Knoll Lumber Legends, Seattle, WA | Nohren Farms, Champaign, IL |
| 1997 | Knoll Lumber Legends, Seattle, WA | Maryland Masters, Waldorf, MD |
| 1998 | Eagle Products, Mishawaka, IN | Maryland Masters, Waldorf, MD |
| 1999 | Decatur Legends, Decatur, IL | Mishawaka Eagle Products, Mishawaka, IN |
| 2000 | Decatur Legends, Decatur, IL | Harold’s Supermarket, Lexington, MO |
| 2001 | Maryland Masters, Waldorf, MD | 51 Classics, Portage, WI |
| 2002 | Harold’s Supermarket, Lexington, MO | Maryland Masters, Waldorf, MD |
| 2003 | Maryland Masters, Waldorf, MD | Harold’s Supermarket, Lexington, MO |
| 2004 | Maryland Masters, Waldorf, MD | Harold’s Supermarket, Lexington, MO |
| 2005 | Seadogs, Boston, MA | Planggers Furniture, Mishawaka, IN |
| 2006 | Seadogs, Boston, MA | Planggers Furniture, Mishawaka, IN |
| 2007 | Cancelled | |
| 2008 | Cancelled | |
| 2009 | Miller Lite, Springfield., MO | Springfield Ducks, Clever, MO |
| 2010 | Maccabi USA, Los Angeles, CA | Tucson A’s, Tucson, AZ |
| 2011 | Columbia River A1 Rockies, Portland, OR | Harold’s Supermarket, Lexington, MO |
| 2012 | Castro Concrete, Austin, TX | Geo-Per, Houston, TX |
| 2013 | Asnom Mustangs, Springfield, MO | Topeka Tin Men, Topeka, KS |
| 2014 | Cancelled | |
| 2015 | Berkenpas Development, Byron Center, MI | Explorer Legends, Midland, MI |
| 2016 | Not Held | |
| 2017 | Not Held | |
| 2018 | Cancelled | |
| 2019 | Cancelled |
