| Year | Champion | Runner-up | MVP |
| 2011 | Vision Softball, Chicago, IL | Pure Smack, Elk Grove, IL | Brian Davis, Vision |
| 2012 | No Fear, Chicago, IL | Gladiators, Chicago, IL | Adrian Alejandro, No Fear |
| 2013 | Nature Boys, Mt. Prospect, IL | Brick, Berwyn, IL | John Ecchardt, Nature Boys |
| 2014 | Young Guns, IL | Rewind, IL | John Reece, Young Guns |
| 2015 | Smackout, Summit, IL | Solutions, Chicago, IL | Kris Stohlmiller, Smackout |
| 2016 | Yep, IL | Blitz, IL | Sean Keanne, Yep |
| 2017 | Hammer the Clam, Whiting, IN | Lose One, IL | Bobby Schuch, Hammer the Clam |
| 2018 | Smackout, Summit, IL | Donuts, IL | Mark Kasper, Smackout |
| 2019 | HOF Concessions, Marshalltown, IA | Bananas, IL | Sam Rogers, HOF Concessions |
| 2020 | YDT, Forest Park, IL | Pharaohs, IL | Jack Doss, YTD |
| 2021 | Ball Busters | Smoke | Tony DiVincenzo, Ball Busters |
