| Year | Champion | Runner-up | MVP |
| 1969 | Marston’s Sporting Goods, Phoenix, AZ | Tappa Keggas, Torrance, CA | Jerry Stiteler, Marston’s Sporting Goods |
| 1970 | Wild Mustangs, Torrance, CA | Los Angeles Old-Timers, Los Angeles, CA | Bob Williams, Wild Mustangs |
| 1971 | Redondo Beach AC, Redondo Beach, CA | Tissaw’s, Flagstaff, AZ | Harry Jenkins, Redondo Beach AC |
| 1972 | Redondo Beach AC, Redondo Beach, CA | Long Beach Seahawks, Long Beach, CA | N/A |
| 1973 | Dependable Trophies, Torrance, CA | Tappa Keggas, Torrance, CA | N/A |
| 1974 | Tully Tappa Keggas, Torrance, CA | Torrance AC, Torrance, CA | Torrance AC, Torrance, CA |
| 1975 | Tappa Keggas, Torrance, CA | Hawthorne Old-Timers, Los Angeles, CA | N/A |
| 1976 | The Beacon, Racine, WI | Saxon Lodge, Hidden Lake, IN | Dick Laba, The Beacon |
| 1976 Western | Salty Dogs, Mosher Beach, CA | Dependable Trophies, Torrance, CA | Ross Pittman, Salty Dogs |
| 1977 | K-Club, Phoenix, AZ | Moe Allen Body Shop, Phoenix, AZ | Kurt Nielson, K-CLUB |
| 1978 | not held | ||
| 1979 | not held | ||
| 1980 | Hiller & Hamm, McHenry, IL | Nancy’s Tavern/Hiller Construction, McHenry, IL | Gary Ryndak, Chicagoans |
| 1981 | C&K Old Style Bobcats, Chicago, IL | Waukegan, IL | Jerry Kelleher, C&K Old Style Bobcats |
| 1982 | Budweiser Whips, Harvey, IL | C&K Old Style Bobcats, Chicago, IL | Mike Tallo, Budweiser Whips |
| 1983 | Budweiser Whips, Harvey, IL | Rat Pack Runts-Rollers, Chicago, IL | John Kelleher, Budweiser Whips |
| 1984 | Budweiser Whips, Harvey, IL | Stompers, Chicago, IL | Jack Kelly, Budweiser Whips |
| 1985 | Stompers, Chicago, IL | Budweiser Whips, Harvey, IL | N/A |
| 1986 | J-Birds, Mt. Prospect, IL | Stompers, Chicago, IL | N/A |
| 1987 | Apple Chevrolet Whips, Harvey, IL | Sports Station, Blue Island, IL | N/A |
| 1988 | Apple Chevrolet Whips, Harvey, IL | Meadows, Rolling Meadows, IL | Dave Brishoff, Apple Chevrolet Whips, Jerry Keller, Apple Chevrolet Defensive MVP |
| 1989 | Bud Light Blues, Mt. Prospect, IL | Pete’s Hideway Whips, Chicago, IL | Gary Mariano, Blues |
| 1990 | Miller Taggers, Mt. Prospect, IL | Aces, Chicago, IL | Ken Butzen, Miller Taggers |
| 1991 | Miller Taggers, Mt. Prospect, IL | March Manufacturing, Glenview, IL | Mike Stout, Miller Taggers |
| 1992 | Old Style Rabbits, Chicago, IL | Stickmen, Chicago, IL | Rich Ladewig, Old Style Rabbits |
| 1993 | Ice Softball, Cicero, IL | L.A. Peacemakers, Chicago, IL | Mike Stout, Ice Softball |
| 1994 | Lettuce, Chicago, IL | Ice, Mt. Prospect, IL | Don Mustari, Lettuce |
| 1995 | Thrashers, Mt. Prospect, IL | Ice House, Chicago, IL | N/A |
Tournament discontinued in 1996.
